WIP: Saltian, Second chances

WIP: Saltian, Second chances

Visited 22 times , 1 Visits today

From section 6, The Pantaloon, of Saltian

Second Chances
By Alice Shapiro
YOUNGER GIRL
In this particular case
much time passed
in solitary confinement
not chained inside a physical prison
parted from the world by bars and guards
but hidden in the corner of an eye
whose depth and breadth of vision
delved far in only one direction – within
like a searchlight on a lonely
lighthouse sandbar
spying distant shipwrecks
searching for a sign of life.
AN OLD GIRL
Like a child develops
to one day see
words appear from single letters,
this old crone was shocked to find
a body connected to her head
not within a physical structure
of sinew and bone
but vibrant in the world of flowers,
hours spent with friends
doing what were once
merely wishful thoughts colliding, parting
staying separate, each alone.
DOWN TO EARTH
It is the glue of mind expanding
ruling who we are 
what phase of darkness 
it is our time to overcome.
Critique
By Jena Salon
In the first section, “Younger Girl,” I love the feeling of yearning and loneliness that’s created by what I imagine is a teenager. The way at that time of life we see our own thoughts and imperfections as separations rather than connections. The idea of a searchlight is nice, but I don’t quite follow the turn to it looking for distant shipwrecks and seeking survivors. You think more of a lighthouse preventing shipwrecks, so if the searchlight is perched on that same sandbar, I think more of it destruction that is so close, and yet you couldn’t prevent it, all you can do is look for survivors.  
The second section, the emotions are right, and it, too, has a strong opening; but the turn to “friends doing what were once merely wishful thoughts colliding” doesn’t make sense to me. The rest of the section is grounded in a way this phrase isn’t. 
The meaning of the last section is nice and ties the other two sections together in a new way. There seems to be something at odds here—something I believe you mean to exploit more fully—between the title “Down to Earth” which coming after a progression from old to young seems to reference death, and the idea of getting second chances for “overcoming”. This could be played up to create more of an arc for the piece—more cohesive with the idea of life—rather than an artificial segmentation. 
#####
Jena Salon is the books editor of The Literary Review. Her essays and reviews have appeared or are forthcoming in n+1, Bookforum, and The Collagist.